My Translation of Ed Milibands Speech (some of you won’t like this)
Thank you Conference.
It’s great to be in Liverpool.
A generation ago a Labour leader came to Conference to condemn the behaviour of a Labour Council in Liverpool.
Today I come to Liverpool, proud to hold our Conference in this great city.
Many of you will already know the history of Liverpool council in the 80’s when they defied the cuts. Today they are implementing £91million of cuts. I would hardly say that’s something worthy of praise.
Proud of the work our Labour council is doing.
Conference, it’s been a busy year for me.
There’s one person I want to thank more than any other.
For her love, her support, for her encouragement.
My wife Justine.
Ask me the three most rewarding things I’ve done this year.
Being at the birth of our second son Sam.
Then getting married.
It is 2011 after all.
And starting to tell Daniel, my older son, the stories my Dad used to tell me.
Ralph Miliband was a socialist. If he was alive to hear his son’s speech I don’t think he would have spotted much socialism in it.
My kids, Daniel and Sam.
A new generation of Miliband brothers.
I know what you’re thinking.
But just to reassure you.
We’re really hoping they become doctors too.
And of course one other big event happened in my life, one that the media was really interested in:
My nose job.
They called it Ed Nose Day.
In case you wondered listening to me, it was a great success.
I had a deviated septum and it needed repositioning.
Typical Labour leader.
He gets elected and everything moves to the centre.
A year ago I was elected your leader.
And I want to thank one colleague in particular for her support over that time.
For her help, her advice, for her friendship, and her commitment to equality and
Harriet Harman, our fantastic deputy leader.
Conference, let’s get down to business.
This is a dangerous time for Britain, and for Britain’s economy.
The Government’s austerity plan is failing.
Funny that because Mr Miliband and co have already stated that they won’t reverse the cuts being forced upon us by the ConDems.
You can sense the fear that people have as we watch the economic crisis that stalked our country in 2008 threatening to return.
No, Mr Miliband, for those of us old enough to remember the 80’s and 90’s, it’s like going back in time, only this time the monsters are bigger, scarier and more real.
Stock markets round the world falling.
The United States in difficulty.
The Eurozone struggling.
And people in Britain losing their jobs.
Now is not the time for the same old answers.
From us, on the issues that lost us your trust.
From this Government, on the growth crisis we face.
You need to know that there is an alternative.
You need to know that it is credible.
So people need to know where I stand.
The Labour Party lost trust on the economy.
And under my leadership, we will regain that trust.
I am determined to prove to you that the next Labour Government will only spend what it can afford.
That we will live within our means.
That we will manage your money properly.
As someone who believes that government can make a difference, I have a special responsibility to show you that every pound that is spent, is spent wisely.
The next Labour Government will still face tough decisions.
We won’t be able to reverse many of the cuts this Government is making.
There is it, they won’t reverse the cuts. Screams of “we’re doomed!” echoed across the country.
And let me tell you, if this Government fails to deal with the deficit in this Parliament, we are determined to do so.
It’s why we will set new fiscal rules to bind government to a disciplined approach.
And it’s right, as a down payment, to tell you that we would use every penny of the sale of bank shares to pay down the debt.
But I have to tell you frankly.
I have a fundamental disagreement with the Government.
They believe Britain can address our problems of debt without addressing our problems of growth.
They are wrong.
Think of how you pay off the credit card bill.
You need to make savings in the household budget.
Can I stop you there Mr Miliband? A government’s budget is rather different to a household budget.
But if you lose your job and the money stops coming in, you can’t pay off the bill.
But you don’t like benefit claimants Mr Miliband (as he clearly discriminates against them later in this speech)
People in Britain are losing their jobs.
They aren’t spending.
Government is cutting back.
And the recovery has stalled.
Of course, the world economy is suffering.
But our Government is making it worse.
Because the current plan to raise taxes and cut spending more dramatically than any other country is not working.
A year ago, lots of people thought the Government was taking the right course.
The Governor of the Bank of England.
The International Monetary Fund.
But one person in particular stood outside the consensus.
Labour’s Shadow Chancellor, Ed Balls.
He was right.
But he is not interested in being proved right.
And nor am I.
I am interested in the Government doing the right thing by the British people.
So there is a big choice facing the country.
Whether to stick on the current plan or to change course?
There is an alternative:
For Britain and other countries to act together to get our economies moving.
Like a VAT cut now to put more money in people’s pockets.
And action to put our young people back to work.
*cough* what about the rest of us? Shouldn’t that be getting everyone who is able, back to work?
I say to David Cameron.
Put the politics aside.
Look at the facts.
Recognise what is staring you in the face.
And understand that protecting our economy matters more than protecting your failed plan.
So I’m going to tell it straight.
That’s the lesson I have learnt about this job and myself over the last twelve months.
To be true to myself.
To take risks in the pursuit of that.
And to stand up for what is right.
The moment it came home to me most was when I heard the terrible news that Milly Dowler’s phone had been hacked.
Someone had hacked into the voicemails of a missing teenager.
Deleted them from her phone.
Given her parents false hope.
As Justine said to me that morning, it was sick that someone could do that.
That’s why I had to speak out.
Wasn’t it Tom Waston and Chris Bryant that spoke out? Yes, you came out criticising afterwards, but they were the brave ones who fought for the scandal to be exposed.
I knew when I said what I did that I was breaking rule number one of British politics.
Don’t mess with Rupert Murdoch.
I did it because it was right.
That’s the lesson I have learned most clearly in the last year.
The lesson that you’ve got to be willing to break the consensus, not succumb to it.
You know, I’m not Tony Blair.
I’m not Gordon Brown either.
Great men, who in their different ways, achieved great things.
I’m my own man.
And I’m going to do things my own way.
That is what it means to lead.
Erm, shouldn’t you be doing what your party wants you to do and not just your own personal crusade or vision?
And I know this.
Nobody ever changed things on the basis of consensus.
Or wanting to be liked.
Or not taking risks.
Or keeping your head down.
It’s a lesson for me and it’s a lesson for my party too.
Don’t believe this stuff about governments losing elections, rather than oppositions winning them.
It sounds to me like a consolation prize for opposition leaders that have lost.
I’m not interested in consolation prizes.
I’ll tell you what I’m interested in.
Winning back the trust of the British people.
Winning the next general election.
My message to the public is this:
We know waiting for the Tories to fail won’t win us back your trust.
And we won’t deserve your trust if that’s what we do.
Paying homage to past leaders won’t win us back your trust.
And we won’t deserve it if that’s what we do.
Asking to carry on where we left off in government won’t win us back your trust.
And we won’t deserve it if that’s what we do.
My top demand of my Shadow Cabinet, my party, my team, is this:
Ambition to change our country.
It’s why we were founded.
It’s in our souls.
It’s the only point in doing the jobs we do.
And it’s the reason I stood to be the leader of this Party.
And it is urgent, at this moment, in Britain 2011.
In every generation, there comes a moment when we need to change the way we do things.
This is one of those moments.
And I believe from our conversations over the past year that you, the British people, know it.
Well, you didn’t read my emails then Mr Miliband because I specifically asked for you to stop slagging off benefit claimants and to actually help us, afterall, the majority of us would work if we could. Signing on or claiming any benefit is soul destroying at the best of times, we really don’t need to be attacked in the press, by party leaders and by members of the public who don’t even know us.
You’ve seen a series of crises hitting our country over the last few years.
This summer’s riots.
Not the first time we’ve seen decent people with the right values losing out to those with the wrong ones.
You are forgetting Mr Miliband that the cause of the riots are complex. It’s not simply about values.
The banking crisis, MPs’ expenses.
Journalists hacking phones.
From them all a something for nothing culture.
Take what you can.
Fill your boots.
Who cares as long as you can get away it.
What about the fact that many involved in the riots did it because they didn’t feel part of their community, they felt excluded. A generation is being created of people with nothing to lose, surely you should be addressing that if you want to be an effective opposition.
And these are just the noisy scandals which grab the front pages.
But you know there’s a quiet crisis which doesn’t get the headlines.
It’s about the people who don’t make a fuss, who don’t hack phones, loot shops, fiddle their expenses, or earn telephone number salaries at the banks.
It’s the grafters, the hard-working majority who do the right thing.
It’s a crisis which is happening in your town, your street and maybe even in your home.
It is a crisis of the promises made over the last thirty years.
The promise that if you’re in work, you will do better each year.
The promise that if you work hard at school the doors of opportunity will open up to you.
The promise that if you teach your kids the difference between right and wrong and bring them up properly, they will get a good job, and a decent home.
These crises point to something deep in our country.
The failure of a system.
A way of doing things.
An old set of rules.
An economy and a society too often rewarding not the right people with the right values, but the wrong people with the wrong values.
So where is the part where you talk about a living wage, cheap or free childcare and lower rents to help those on low wages to not just survive, but to actually live?
So the task of leadership in this generation is no ordinary task.
It is to chart a new course.
And strike a new bargain in our country.
That’s what I want to talk to you about today.
Let’s be clear about one thing.
The problem isn’t the people of Britain.
That depends which side of the line you’re on.
I saw it when I met our troops in Afghanistan.
Brave men and women.
Called to serve our country.
At this moment, as we meet in the comfort of this hall, hundreds, thousands of our troops are risking their lives.
In harm’s way, so far from home.
We should think of them today and every day.
Let’s all thank them and acknowledge the heroism they show on behalf of our country.
And as always in our history, we see the true British character in moments of crisis.
We saw it during the riots.
It was a terrible moment for Britain.
People looting shops, burning cars.
It even happened right by my old school.
But for every person that looted, there were hundreds, thousands who said this will not stand and came out to help with the clean up.
I saw it in Manchester, people of all generations, who came out the next morning to get the city back on its feet.
Those young people with the brooms.
Those young people who join us at Conference today.
I’m pretty certain it wasn’t just Labour Party members who organised the clean up operation. I distinctly remember seeing alot of my friends organising clean ups online.
And let us celebrate what they did.
Let us celebrate too those brave police officers who worked day and night to bring order to our streets.
While alot of police officers are good at their job and should be praised, you are forgetting the girl who was beaten up the first night of the riots by police officers, and also the death of Mark Duggan. You are also forgetting the officers who failed to protect small business’ and homes to protect larger national chains.
They put themselves in harm’s way and we should thank them for it.
Citizens and public servants alike.
Theirs are the true values of Britain.
They are the true face of Britain.
And when we talk about the places where the riots happened, let’s remember that the vast majority of people who live there are decent, law-abiding, community-spirited.
We must punish those who do wrong.
But I’m not with the Prime Minister.
I will never write off whole parts of our country by calling them sick.
We are not a country of bad people but great people.
Great people in a great country.
Ready to celebrate the Olympics next year.
Olympic Britain 2012, ready to light up the world.
Excuse me if I don’t share your enthusiasm…
But with such great people, how have we ended up with the problems we face?
It’s because of the way we have chosen to run our country.
Not just for a year or so but for decades.
Now there are hard lessons here for my party which some won’t like.
Some of what happened in the 1980s was right.
Not in my world it wasn’t
It was right to let people buy their council houses.
I’d agree if those council houses had been replaced with new ones but they weren’t.
It was right to cut tax rates of 60, 70, 80 percent.
And it was right to change the rules on the closed shop, on strikes before ballots.
Not winning any fans here from the unions.
These changes were right, and we were wrong to oppose it at the time.
No, you are wrong to be praising the work of Thatcher.
But while some of it was right, too much of what happened was based on the wrong values.
That’s where New Labour came in.
The rebuilt schools, new hospitals, more police.
The minimum wage, tax credits, the new deal.
Half a million children lifted out of poverty.
Britain with Labour: the only country in Europe where poverty was not going up, but was going down.
My party is proud of that record.
And so am I.
Thankyou for the tax credits. Can I have a living wage now or free childcare so that I can go back to work and not have to use my oldest daughter as childcare when Universal Credit comes into force, or are you just going to sit back and watch as her life is destroyed?
But good times did not mean we had a good economic system.
We changed the fabric of our country but we did not do enough to change the values of our economy.
You believe rewards should be for hard work.
But you’ve been told we have to tolerate the wealthiest taking what they can.
And what’s happened?
Your living standards have been squeezed by runaway rewards at the top.
Our living standards at the bottom are being decimated, not just squeezed but you like to talk about the ‘squeezed middle’ and ignore the rest of us.
You believe we owe duties to each other.
But in our economy you’ve been told that duties to each other come second.
And so while many companies do the right thing and train their workforce, others do not.
And what’s happened?
You’ve seen your sons and daughters not getting an apprenticeship, stuck in a job where they can’t progress.
We are seeing our children thrown onto the dole, apprenticeships aren’t everything Mr Miliband, some young people would like a job with a real wage.
And we have seen immigration policy which didn’t work for the people whose jobs, living standards and communities were affected.
I don’t believe that immigration had any negative affect on my life.
You believe in the values of the long-term.
But in our economy, you’ve been told the fast buck is ok.
And what’s happened?
We’ve ended up with a financial crisis and you’ve ended up footing the bill.
You believe in a society where everybody is responsible for their actions.
But you’ve been told that if companies are big enough or powerful enough they can get away with anything.
And what’s happened?
Big vested interests like the energy companies have gone unchallenged, while you’re being ripped off.
So you have been told for too long that the only way our economy can succeed is if we reward not your values, but a totally different set of values.
The triumph of finance over industry.
The victory of vested interests over the public interest.
And who’s been rewarded in this economy?
Take Fred Goodwin, who ran the Royal Bank of Scotland.
He was at the heart of the banking crisis.
Compare him to Sir John Rose, former Chief Executive of Rolls Royce, a great British business leader.
Creating wealth and keeping jobs in this country.
He is the true face of British business.
The vast majority of our businesses that have the right values and do the right thing.
Rooted in their communities.
Committed to their workforce.
And creating real, lasting value.
But at the time of the financial crisis, Fred Goodwin was paid over three times more than Sir John Rose.
I tell you something, Fred Goodwin shouldn’t have got that salary.
And I tell you something else:
We shouldn’t have given Sir Fred Goodwin that knighthood either.
You know what your values are.
You believe in looking out for each other.
You believe we are stronger together.
Weaker on our own.
But we have allowed values which say take what you can, I’m in it for myself, to create a Britain that is too unequal.
The people at the top taking unjustified rewards isn’t just bad for our economy.
It sends a message throughout our society about what values are ok.
And inequality reinforces privilege and opportunity for the few.
You know what your values are.
You believe whether you get on shouldn’t depend on where you come from but what you have it within you to become.
Those are Britain’s values.
Reward linked to effort.
Something for something.
But as the rungs of the ladder grow further and further apart, the chance of climbing up, becomes harder.
Think of some of the kids at school today in my constituency, in Doncaster.
Or in your town.
Ask yourself, what are their chances, however bright, of getting into one of the top universities, competing against people with all the chances in life?
Of having the network of connections that will set them up for their career?
21st century Britain: still a country for the insiders.
What’s my story?
My parents fled the Nazis.
And came to Britain.
They embraced its values.
Who built a life for us.
So this is who I am.
The heritage of the outsider.
The vantage point of the insider.
The guy who is determined to break the closed circles of Britain.
And as young people confront the choices they have in life, they see routes to success today based on a wrong set of values.
The something for nothing of celebrity culture.
The take what you can of the gangs.
And in parts of some of our communities, a life on benefits.
And here it is. Comparing benefit claimants with bankers, celebrities, gangs and greed. Extremely offensive Mr Miliband but at least this time we weren’t compared to phone hackers.
You know what your values are.
But they are not the values being rewarded in our benefits system.
We must never excuse people who cheat the welfare system.
True, but your words will not justify innocent people being abused by ignorant others who have no understanding of the actual fraud statistics.
“Fraud and Error in the Benefit System: Preliminary 2010/11 Estimates
- For 2010/11, it is estimated that 2.1 per cent of total benefit expenditure was overpaid due to fraud and error. This is down from the 2009/10 level of 2.2%.
- The estimated value of overpayments is £3.3bn which is the same value as in 2009/10.
- For 2010/11, it is estimated that 0.8 per cent of total expenditure was underpaid, a fall from 0.9 per cent in 2009/10.
- The estimated value of underpayments is £1.3bn which is the same value as in 2009/10. “
The reason I talk about this is not because I don’t believe in a welfare state but because I do.
We can never protect and renew it if people believe it’s just not fair.
If it’s too easy not to work.
Mr Miliband, you have no experience of the benefit system, you’ve never claimed benefit, never will. It is far from easy and the amounts we receive are not in any way extravagant! Come and see me, I’ll show you how I plan to pay my gas and electric bill, the rent and then attempt to feed my little family. You may learn a thing or two.
And there are people taking something for nothing.
And if at the same time people who have paid into the system all their lives find the safety net full of holes.
No wonder people are angry.
What about those who are disabled from birth? Unable to work through no fault of their own, what exactly do you want to do to them? For the record I have paid into the system, but that doesn’t stop the ignoramus’ pointing and whispering when I’m out with my children, and it doesn’t stop decent people being spat on and attacked in the street by people who hang on every word they hear from politicians and the press. How heartbroken would you be Mr Miliband if another child told one of your children their mother was scum? It’ll never happen to you but it happens to us, all the time! You’ve never gone through the humiliation of an Atos assessment, I know alot of people who have, and alot who had to fight for the benefits they rightly deserve to receive.
It’s my job, my Party’s mission
To say: no more.
It’s all got to change.
Bracing myself for certain doom now.
We need a new bargain.
Based on Britain’s values.
Britain’s values in our economy, in our society, and in the way our country is run.
Let’s confront head on the big challenge we face of building a new bargain in our economy.
Built on values of hard work, something for something, the long-term.
Can you also pop in something about protecting the most vulnerable in society?
We need a new era of wealth creation in this country.
But it will not happen with the old set of rules.
And we can’t spend our way to a new economy.
We are competing not just with Germany and Japan, but with China, India and Brazil.
Don’t believe those who would tell you that the kind of economy we have now will help us to compete in that world.
We can’t pay our way unless as a country we invent things, make things, and sell real services and products.
Britain’s future will be built not on credit default swaps but on creative industries.
Not low wages and high finance, but low carbon and high tech.
Not financial engineering, but real engineering.
Of course, the banks and financial services are important to Britain.
They employ people right across the country.
They will still be important to Britain in the future.
But they must change so that they are part of the solution to our economic future, not part of the problem.
You’ve been told all growth is the same, all ways of doing business are the same.
But it’s not.
You’ve been told that the choice in politics is whether parties are pro-business or anti-business.
But all parties must be pro-business today.
If it ever was, that’s not the real choice any more.
Let me tell you what the 21st century choice is:
Are you on the side of the wealth creators or the asset strippers?
The producers or the predators?
I’m on the side of whoever will enable my children to succeed, and not just in financial terms either!
Producers train, invest, invent, sell.
Things Britain does brilliantly.
Predators are just interested in the fast buck, taking what they can out of the business.
This isn’t about one industry that’s good and another that isn’t.
Or one firm always destined to be a predator and another to be a producer.
It’s about different ways of doing business, ways that the rules of our economy can favour or discourage.
Look at what a private equity firm did to the Southern Cross care homes.
Stripping assets for a quick buck and treating tens of thousands of elderly people like commodities to be bought and sold.
They may not have sold their own grandmothers for a fast buck.
But they certainly sold yours.
They aren’t the values of British business.
It must change.
It must never happen again in the new economy we build.
We must learn the lesson that growth is built on sand if it comes from our predators and not our producers.
For years as a country we have been neutral in that battle.
They’ve been taxed the same.
The ones who bother to pay their taxes.
Regulated the same.
Treated the same.
Celebrated the same.
They won’t be by me.
We need the most competitive tax and regulatory environment we can for British business.
But when I am Prime Minister, how we tax, what government buys, how we regulate, what we celebrate will be in the service of Britain’s producers.
And don’t let anyone tell you that this is the anti-business choice.
It’s the pro-business choice.
Pro-business on the side of the small businesses who can’t get a loan.
Pro-business on the side of high value manufacturing that can’t build its business because of the short-termist culture.
Pro-business on the side of the British company losing out to its competitors abroad when their government steps in and our government stands aside.
And that includes companies like Bombardier and BAe systems.
Almost 3000 employees of BAe were told that they are facing the dole queue, while Mr Miliband attacks benefit claimants.
Being sold down the river by this Government.
Just like Sheffield Forgemasters before them.
Having Nick Clegg as the local MP didn’t help much.
You know, the boundary review means his seat will be represented by a Tory after the next election.
No change there then.
I’m sure the people of Sheffield were all falling about laughing…..
Supporting the producers, that is what it means to be pro-business today.
That is why I say all major government contracts will go to firms who commit to training the next generation with decent apprenticeships.
So, no apprenticeships, no work ladies and gentlemen.
And none will go to those who don’t.
And it is also why I say, the new bargain in our economy must be built on co-operation not conflict in the workplace.
Raising productivity, working together, helping firms to compete.
That is the most important future for the trade unions in this country.
And we must challenge irresponsible, predatory practices wherever we find them.
We need investment in energy here in Britain.
But our energy companies have defied the laws of gravity for too long.
Prices go up but they never seem to come down.
I believe our environment and climate change is a crucial issue for our future.
An essential part of the new bargain.
Responsibility, commitment for the long term:
That’s what my kids will want from us on the environment when they grow up and ask whether we were the first generation to get it or the last generation not to.
So over time there is going to be upward pressure on energy prices.
But that makes it all the more important we get the best possible deal for customers.
So let’s break the dominance of the big energy companies.
Let’s call a rigged market what it is.
And get a fairer deal for the people of Britain.
But as we challenge the predators let’s celebrate Britain’s producers.
Wherever we find them.
If people make money and profit through hard work, hard graft, something for something, let’s praise them.
I’m confused now, is he saying he’s going to make energy companies lower their prices, or praise them for working hard and getting rich?
And let me tell you what the problem is with these Tories.
They don’t understand who the real wealth creators of this country are.
Or the values our economy needs for them to succeed.
They talk as if the CEOs and the executives are the only people who create wealth.
Of course great business leaders make a huge difference to our country, and I applaud them.
But the small businesses that are the lifeblood of our economy are also the wealth creators.
The scientists and innovators are also our wealth creators.
And the young apprentices are also the wealth creators.
The wealth of our nation is built by the hands not just of the elite few but every man and woman who goes out and does a day’s work.
The Tories aren’t building a new bargain that supports the right people with the right values.
But they don’t like the people at the bottom either Mr Miliband…..
Young people, doing the right thing, wanting to go to higher education are going to find that their hard work and ambition will be punished with tens of thousands of pounds of debt.
Agreed but your idea of 6k tuition fees is frankly insulting.
And yet at the same time, George Osborne plans cuts in corporation tax for the banks.
It’s the wrong choice.
Now some of you would like no fees at all.
I understand that.
But it wouldn’t be responsible to make promises I can’t keep.
So work out how to make it so then!
That’s Nick Clegg’s job.
Let me tell you what I would do.
If we were in government now, we’d be cutting the costs of going to university from a maximum of £9,000 to £6,000.
A pathetic token
To the young people who want to get on and contribute to our country my message is simple.
I won’t let you be priced out of your future.
Labour is on your side.
Too late, my children are already priced out of college, let alone university.
We can’t afford to carry on with so many young people locked out of opportunity.
Three thousand of our brightest young people, at state schools, get the grades to go to our most competitive universities.
But they never go.
That can’t be right.
It creates a sense that there is no something for something deal.
I went to a fantastic local school.
It was a tough area but it was a school that changed lives.
But the truth is that the problem in some of our schools is not just investment.
It’s also about values.
Of bright children held back when aspirations are low.
Or when closed circles at the top of society shut them out.
In any one year more than a quarter of our schools don’t even send five kids to the most competitive universities.
Is anyone seriously telling me that there aren’t pupils at any of those schools who are good enough to go?
It’s got to change.
And we will change it.
Here is my challenge to those schools and universities.
Raise your game.
To the schools not doing enough I say:
Lift your ambition, lift your sights.
To the universities not opening up I say:
Open your eyes, open your doors.
But their funding’s been cut you idiot!
Say to the very brightest children at every school: if you get the grades, you’ll get a place.
And it’s not just in our schools that I want to change the values that get rewarded.
It’s right across society.
The new bargain must demand responsibility from all.
We’ve got to put an end to the idea that those at the top can take whatever they can, regardless of what they give back.
It’s why we must end the cosy cartels of the way top pay is set in our economy.
So every pay committee should have an employee on the board.
And the something for something deal requires that sacrifice as well as prosperity is fairly shared.
Have you noticed how uncomfortable David Cameron is when he has to talk about responsibility at the very top?
He found it easy to be tough on you.
VAT went up.
He called it a tough decision.
Tax credits were cut.
He said they couldn’t be afforded.
Help paying for childcare was hit.
He said it was the only thing he could do.
When you have had to pay, it’s always necessary, it’s always permanent, it can never be reversed.
And yet at the same time they are straining at the leash to cut the 50p tax rate for people earning over £3,000 a week.
Only David Cameron could believe that you make ordinary families work harder by making them poorer and you make the rich work harder by making them richer.
Mr Miliband I agree with you there.
It’s the wrong priority.
It’s based on the wrong values.
How dare they say we’re all in it together.
Mr Miliband, you are not one of us. You do not struggle. We are all in the shit together, you are not.
So we need a new bargain at the top of society, and in our benefits system too.
Again with the benefits!
So it rewards the right people with the right values.
But it isn’t delivering that.
And we’ve got to fix it.
If you think putting it right means just stripping away welfare then you are better off with Iain Duncan Smith and David Cameron.
But at the same time we have to face the truth.
Even after reforms of recent years, we still have a system where reward for work is not high enough.
Where benefits are too easy to come by for those who don’t deserve them and too low for those who do.
Mr Miliband, if you had ever had to claim benefits you would know that it is anything but easy. I would like to see you fill the forms out, do the interview, and then wait for the payment. I’d also like to see you go through the humiliation of applying for a crisis loan when a payment is late, they lost your paperwork, or you have been sanctioned for nothing. Try explaining to your landlord why you’re rent payment is late because the council are on a go slow, and try arguing with a council that wants to take you to court for council tax that they are supposed to be paying! (wrong reference number meant I was summonsed to court) Try going to an Atos assessment, then tell us it’s easy!
So if what you want is a welfare system that works for working people then I’m prepared to take the tough decisions to make that a reality.
More working people claim housing benefit than unemployed people Mr Miliband…
Take social housing.
When we have a housing shortage, choices have to be made.
Yes, it’s the homeless and people with medical needs first, as it should be. (google it)
Why don’t you say you’re going to build more social housing?
Do we treat the person who contributes to their community the same as the person who doesn’t?
Please, define what you class as a contribution to society? I am raising the next generation, is that not worthy of being classed as a contribution to society?
My answer is no.
Our first duty should be to help the person who shows responsibility.
And I say every council should recognise the contribution that people are making.
David Cameron likes to talk tough on welfare, but do you know who the big losers are from his changes?
Time and again it’s those who work hard, who try to get on.
No, it’s those who claim benefits who lose out, numpty!
It’s the cancer patients who have worked all their lives but now lose their support.
It’s the couple who have put money aside and saved, but now lose their tax credits.
And it is the single mum working as a dinner lady who loses help with her childcare.
Don’t forget the single parent running from domestic violence, living in a hostel. The autistic child stripped of benefits, the lady crippled with arthritis just deemed fit for work. The parents working full time, forced to have one give up work because the tax credits aren’t enough to make it pay, claiming housing benefit because they cant pay their rent. The man with a brain injury who looks like you or me but has severe mental health problems and is unable to work. Cancer patients are a favourite with politicians, they should also include the other victims too. (Just to point out, a single mum working as a dinner lady only needs childcare if her children are not of school age, seeing as a dinner lady only works during school hours.)
And we have got to change it.
And while those who do the right thing are hit hard, the demands on those who don’t work aren’t tough enough.
You fail to distinguish between those who wont and those who can’t.
Gone is the something for something requirement that every young person out of work for six months will be required to work.
You haven’t heard of the Work Programme then? The slave labour programme?
This Government won’t make the commitment to help our young people back to work.
It’s wrong and we would change it.
Decency, fairness, helping those who do the right thing.
I believe in a benefits system with values.
Nothing wrong with my values Mr Miliband. You create jobs that fit around my children, a decent wage and give me some responsible childcare and I’ll do it.
And I believe in the value of work.
So do I. I work alot harder than any politician. My shift never ends. If I was paid by the hour I’d be a millionaire.
Think about that word.
The party of work.
Shouldn’t that be the party of the working class?
Now under my leadership, we will be the party which makes welfare work too.
And it’s not just in our benefits system that I want to change the way government works.
It’s in our public services as well.
Millions of public servants deliver a fantastic service every day of every week.
But we all know that sometimes powerful organisations can become unaccountable.
Work not in the interests of those who need them but in their own interests.
That’s what vested interests are.
My task, our responsibility, is to make government work better for people.
The patient frustrated when they can’t be seen by the person they want.
The victim of crime who just wants their case properly investigated.
You know what it’s like.
You stand in the queue.
You hang on the phone.
You fill in the form.
And then all you get?
Computer says no.
Sounds like the jobcentre…
We need to change that.
To give power to the public.
Like the power to the elderly couple to choose whether they are cared for in a care home or in their own home.
Or the parents I know struggling with their council on their child’s special needs who want to know who else is facing the same challenges.
Who want the council to act!
So I will take on the vested interests wherever they are because that is how we defend the public interest.
And there is no greater public interest than our National Health Service.
Cherished by all of us.
Founded by Labour.
Saved by Labour.
Today defended by Labour once again.
Why does Britain care so much for the NHS?
Because, more than any other institution in our country, the values of the NHS are our values.
It doesn’t matter who you are.
Or what you earn.
The NHS offers the highest quality care when we need it.
I saw it this year with the birth of our son, Sam.
Like millions of other families, mine had the best of care from doctors, nurses.
And nobody asked me for my credit card at the door.
And when I look at everything this Tory Government is doing, it is the NHS that shocks me most.
Because David Cameron told us he was different.
David Cameron knew the British people did not trust the Tories with our NHS.
So he told us he wasn’t the usual type of Tory.
And he asked for your trust.
And then he got into Downing Street.
And within a year – within a year – he’d gone back on every word he’d said.
No more top-down reorganisations?
He betrayed your trust.
No more hospital closures?
He betrayed your trust.
No more long waits?
He betrayed your trust.
And the biggest betrayal of all?
The values of the NHS.
The values he promised to protect.
Hospitals to be fined millions of pounds if they break the rules of David Cameron’s free-market healthcare system.
The old values that have failed our economy now being imported to our most prized institution: the NHS.
Let me tell David Cameron this.
It’s the oldest truth in politics.
He knows it and now the public know it.
You can’t trust the Tories with the NHS.
And let me tell the British people:
If you want someone who will rip up the old rules so that the country works for you, don’t expect it from this Prime Minister.
On the 50p tax rate, on the banks, on the closed circles of Britain, on welfare, on the NHS, he’s not about a new set of rules.
He’s the last gasp of the old rules.
The wrong values for our country and the wrong values for our time.
You know Britain needs to change.
Every day of your life seems like a tough fight.
To make ends meet.
To do the best by your kids.
To look after your Mum or Dad.
And it will be a tough fight to change Britain.
But I’m up for the fight.
The fight for a new bargain.
A new bargain in our economy so reward is linked to effort.
A new bargain based on your values so we can pay our way in the world.
A new bargain to ensure responsibility from top to bottom.
And a new bargain to break open the closed circles, and break up vested interests, that hold our country back.
I aspire to be your Prime Minister not for more of the same.
But to write a new chapter in our country’s history.
The promise of Britain lies in its people.
The tragedy of Britain is that it is not being met.
To fulfil the promise of each so we fulfil the promise of Britain.
Is the bargain like the new deal? Is the promise like the american dream? If so I’m not really interested thanks. I expect to live in a country where we look after those who need help, where we encourage our kids to be upstanding members of society, look after each other and not judge each other based on their financial position. I expect to live in a country where I am not attacked by politicians because I’m a mother who needs childcare to work. I expect the leader of the opposition not to tell people that those on benefits should be discriminated against when applying for housing. Do you realise Mr Miliband that living in the private sector is a disincentive to working? Living in social housing means lower rent, which makes it easier to go to work because we have a better chance of paying that rent. It costs the tax payer alot more to house us in the private sector.
I saw a so called socialist online last night declare that all benefit claimants should be refused social housing because they are a drain on the public purse. Funny kind of socialism there methinks. Refusing those on the bottom rung any help seems like a Tory idea to me.
Mr Miliband, you also failed to mention the ‘compulsory employment workshops’. I don’t need a workshop, I know how to apply for a job. I need a job that’s not a temporary agency job, with suitable hours, a good wage and childcare I can actually afford! Right now, if I was working full time, which I want to do, my childcare bill would be around £450 a week. With tax credits that would be around £130 a week. I’m unlikely to earn much more than that to be honest with you, so what do I do? I don’t need soundbites, silly jokes about Nick Clegg or someone who thinks anything Margaret Thatcher did was right. I need someone who is going to give our kids back their youth services, give them their EMA back, get rid of tuition fees and stop encouraging the right wing to attack those of us at the bottom who are being crushed! Could you get rid of Atos aswell please so that so many of my friends don’t have to live in terror anymore? Stand up Mr Miliband and be the socialist you declared you were last year instead of the blue labour, purple labour whatever colour it is this week labour that you have morphed into.
Oh and another thing, I’ll be supporting the strikes on November 30th. People fighting for their pensions, people joining forces to fight the kind of barbaric cuts you praised Liverpool council for implementing. Those are the values I want in this country, not discrimination against the poor, empty speeches or someone with no understanding of poverty deciding he has some god given right to lecture those who live in it.
I’m very sorry if some of you don’t like this but it is my own personal view. My dad taught me to have my own mind and make my own decisions. He’s always voted labour and I love him for it but even he says “our country is only democratic on election day and that’s debateable”. He’s paid his taxes and contrary to what Mr Miliband thinks, he loves the welfare state, he loves the fact that people can claim benefits when they can’t work, and he loves immigration. He retired last month, mum’s petrified they’re going to starve or freeze to death, she feels guilty because she won’t be able to help me and my older brother if we get into difficulties, and she’s scared for the future for her grandchildren. Last year they told me to keep my head down, behave, don’t get into trouble. Now they tell me to go out, shout loud and do whatever it takes to stop us all being treated this way. How many of you who cheered Mr Miliband’s speech will be out there with me?
I have just heard that the leader of Liverpool council is extremely unhappy with Mr Miliband’s ideas of discriminating against the unemployed. Will link to it when a link is available.